Riposte

Sunday, January 28, 2007

 paid wikipedia edits really a bad thing?
Just recently there was an outburst of controversy on Wikipedia when it was reported that Microsoft asked an editor to make some edits and receive compensation. Microsoft was unsettled by some of the inaccuracies and over criticisms of their file types in their respective Wikipedia articles. Since anyone can edit Wikipedia, Microsoft could have easily edited these articles themselves, they instead attempted to hire a neutral 3rd party that would re-write the articles with a more balanced view.

This upset many a Wikipedian, including Jimbo Wales, the founder of Wikipedia. Jimbo calls this pratice "'antithetical' to Wikipedia's mission". I find this a bit bizzare. Wikipedia already has a defense mechanism to react to bad edits. If an edit is made, anyone else can do anything from as small as remove a sentence or two, or reverting the entire edit to its previous state. This defense should be enough to prevent the majority of such paid editors from making such bad edits, and keep their good edits in check.

Wikipedia already allows compensation via a special message board in which people request certain edits be made or criteria met in a particular article. Compensation for such edits can either be a monetary amount or they may be requested to be done for free.
Offers for barter or even cash are common on the forum, and the person making the offer can remain anonymous. Indeed, on Wednesday, someone was ponying up $55 for whoever could get an article about Lithuania to reach featured status.
I've found that while browsing Wikipedia some seemingly important topics are left with very short articles, or stubs, which leave you searching for information elsewhere on the internet. Paid editors point out the following:
"It is strange that a minor Pokemon character will get a 1,200-word article, but a Fortune 500 company will get ... maybe 100 words," he said.
I think Wikipedia is already set up to easily handle and bad edits made and these pratices should not be prevented or frowned upon.
Comments Post a Comment
return to the front page

ABOUT ME
jay reed iii (wikipedia)
25 • male
criminal justice • camden county college
winsow townshipnew jerseyusa

WHERE AM I


MUSIC

weekly top ten bands from last.fm

FRIENDS' BLOGS
duncaniainbryn

ARCHIVES
01.2006 02.2006 03.2006 04.2006 05.2006 06.2006 07.2006 08.2006 09.2006 10.2006 11.2006 12.2006 01.2007 02.2007 03.2007 04.2007 05.2007 06.2007 07.2007 08.2007 09.2007 10.2007 11.2007 12.2007 01.2008 02.2008 03.2008 04.2008 05.2008 06.2008 07.2008 08.2008 09.2008 10.2008 11.2008 12.2008 01.2009 02.2009 03.2009 04.2009 05.2009

PHOTOS

picasaflickr

XBOX360
A1337haxor's Gamercard
my xbox can blog (rss)

READER

Powered by Blogger i power blogger
syndicate
     - add to google


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License.